The problem with cosmetic parts is that you want them to be perfect. And if the defect looks like some random dent or scrape, then you don't want that part, it's not as good as an undented or unscraped part. I get that. Bestem also gets that, people have bought direct from them on eBay, and they have corrected issues without all the Bayside drama. Would have been better if it was a bellypan, at least you don't have to look at that every time you ride the bike.